World ( The cow news digital ) Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry, Director General of ISPR, had raised a series of critical questions regarding the Pahalgam incident during a press briefing on April 30, 2025, but those concerns remain unanswered even a year later, according to official statements.
During the briefing, Lt. Gen. Ahmed Sharif Chaudhry emphasized the importance of examining facts rather than relying on allegations. He questioned claims that the attack was carried out by militants crossing from Pakistani territory, pointing out that Pahalgam is located more than 200 kilometers away from the nearest Pakistani area, making such infiltration highly improbable given the difficult terrain.
He further highlighted logistical inconsistencies, noting that the region is mountainous and lacks infrastructure that would allow rapid movement. According to him, reaching the nearest police station from the site of the incident would take at least 30 minutes under normal circumstances.
One of the key concerns raised was the timeline mentioned in the First Information Report (FIR). The DG ISPR pointed out that the police reportedly arrived at the scene, assessed the situation, and registered a report within just 10 minutes — a sequence he described as highly questionable and indicative of possible prior knowledge or preparation.
He also questioned how Indian authorities were able to attribute responsibility to cross-border elements almost immediately after the attack, despite the absence of any prior intelligence warning. This rapid narrative formation, he argued, raised doubts about the credibility of the claims.
Addressing the communal angle, Chaudhry rejected assertions that the attack targeted individuals based on religion. He stated that terrorism cannot be linked to any specific faith, emphasizing that such narratives are often used to shape public perception rather than reflect ground realities.
The DG ISPR further claimed that even within India, voices had emerged questioning the official version of events. He noted that certain social media accounts, allegedly linked to Indian agencies, began circulating accusations against Pakistan within minutes of the incident.
read more
- Imran Khan and the Politics of Idolization
- Pakistan, Taliban, and Afghanistan: The Complex Triangle of Influence
According to Pakistani officials, these developments suggest a coordinated effort to construct a narrative without presenting verifiable evidence. The briefing concluded with a call for transparency and factual investigation into the incident.
One year on, Pakistani authorities maintain that the questions raised during the briefing have yet to receive any formal or satisfactory response from the Indian side.
